data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8db7c/8db7c8df116dafa42ed7e4f503c3438f519b445d" alt="large.jpg //timgm.eprice.com.hk/hk/mobile/img/2015-03/28/201515/lawrencelaw_1_4523_424c28cc70340f17e9fd32bdf31d6145.jpg"
主鏡頭比較:Galaxy S6 像素較高, Zenfone 2 拍攝模式更多
首先要先跟大家說明,我們將兩款手機都開啟最高像素作為測試標準,其中 Galaxy S6 最高像素為 1600 萬,比例為 16:9;而 ZenFone 2 (是次測試所用為 4GB RAM 版本)最高像素是 1300 萬,比例為 4:3,因此在成像上會有比例的差異。而一般場景拍攝時,兩款手機皆關閉 HDR 功能,只有在逆光場景中,才將 HDR 模式開啟。至於夜拍部分,Galaxy S6 沒有夜拍模式,所以我們以自動和開啟 HDR 兩種模式來做拍攝;至於 ZenFone 2 除了自動模式以外,還擁有夜拍跟低光源模式,其中低光源模式會自動縮為 3MP,所以原圖裁切的時候比例會比較不一樣。 此外,以下成像左邊皆為實拍縮圖,大家可以點擊放大檢視原圖;至於右邊則是原圖的對焦點裁切,讓大家可以看看各別手機實際畫質的表現。
一般場景(一)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/36bcb/36bcbfbb16fd588916d8a0afa6eff6843ef284df" alt="20150318_155858.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_155858.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4a819/4a819139bd3a3240b05d58ecfab48b415d0a684d" alt="20150318_1558580.jpg 20150318_1558580.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53bee/53beec11a3a61d956c6c56fc3f7952719577df94" alt="P_20150318_155848.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_155848.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b1bf2/b1bf241a8b4a8bca923c451f96d5bcc0d85a9594" alt="P_20150318_1558480.jpg P_20150318_1558480.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
一般場景(二)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/28afa/28afaa043915b04e56d929693dea957a62ab1bf0" alt="20150318_163214.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_163214.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/83b8a/83b8a18b142c304c0271294afeb74825428c63da" alt="20150318_1632140.jpg 20150318_1632140.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1832a/1832a90f6c706db5f7b9a500e4d0b6f948961370" alt="P_20150318_163205.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_163205.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c7429/c7429c31bb7cf521d5a292a4ce5f7d487c4f4f6f" alt="P_20150318_1632050.jpg P_20150318_1632050.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
一般場景(三)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4a695/4a6955e4857e27c1da4dafd616042628b25675b6" alt="20150318_160825.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_160825.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a038b/a038bb64110191adc0d2863732f75a6bc627c79e" alt="20150318_1608250.jpg 20150318_1608250.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f485d/f485de63a41150f7614bf84165cc6f7a1eb0e22f" alt="P_20150318_160811.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_160811.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d65b8/d65b83b7f7cc1bc59bbfacfb8d81a3a83650709b" alt="P_20150318_1608110.jpg P_20150318_1608110.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
逆光場景 HDR 開啟 (一)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7543d/7543d4a341328a0ef262fb54fc4b1b83eccb1df9" alt="20150318_160456.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_160456.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8a0c7/8a0c7f22a5359df89a068be33a1527c94351ad77" alt="20150318_1604560.jpg 20150318_1604560.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b92db/b92dbe7505ee49de90500e02424714bd1ea5a42a" alt="P_20150318_160524_HDR.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_160524_HDR.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fd7bf/fd7bff244138ecdeaaa6324771de25330ee8674f" alt="P_20150318_160524_HDR0.jpg P_20150318_160524_HDR0.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
逆光場景 HDR 開啟 (二)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/10531/10531c22f2a9c60824408d86d8663326dfa57eee" alt="20150318_160900.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_160900.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d8bf7/d8bf7916739947520d6d7a9dbc7abe1a1c86eead" alt="20150318_1609000.jpg 20150318_1609000.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cb317/cb317f23dc5345a0bec12d1ec4a75ac02f03841a" alt="P_20150318_160848_HDR.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_160848_HDR.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/da747/da747cf26b9bacf348d11fb53f80e0a14de356b7" alt="P_20150318_160848_HDR0.jpg P_20150318_160848_HDR0.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
逆光場景 HDR 開啟 (三)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f5c35/f5c352d576ea3301c7e4b6b10ea339384d1be13f" alt="20150318_161318.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_161318.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/319cc/319cc23a40235655d9c00202b3f66d4f54f1e5bf" alt="20150318_1613180.jpg 20150318_1613180.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/83a46/83a46e3c1e3d948e9d1e169945ac3bf981d0d2b2" alt="P_20150318_161346_HDR.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_161346_HDR.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2add8/2add88951d8313db744d547faa9d76c06552784d" alt="P_20150318_161346_HDR0.jpg P_20150318_161346_HDR0.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
近拍場景 (一)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/91bc9/91bc9098160056e6d09e6479afb19ff333ad6569" alt="20150318_162719_001.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_162719_001.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/adc16/adc16f367240e00be85bb7045c009b3ea4d9d2a7" alt="20150318_162719_0010.jpg 20150318_162719_0010.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f4abd/f4abd902f69155d3d774aaceb6fff4c97bf080cf" alt="P_20150318_162709.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_162709.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9105a/9105af3fa6b9cb1d4c7f4861ac45e0f2f6ce5b87" alt="P_20150318_1627090.jpg P_20150318_1627090.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
近拍場景 (二)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9e4f4/9e4f491c93e3d4f31ab54db703fe6a6d6e78aa6f" alt="20150318_162841.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_162841.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/93d91/93d918399a76148ca87f8d3d060103f4a0b523ec" alt="20150318_1628410.jpg 20150318_1628410.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8a64b/8a64b4ca18322b4f5644f80f246c9acad31ba3d7" alt="P_20150318_163009.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_163009.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2ff7b/2ff7b1facd25fb12ecdc83e1498830a41626e949" alt="P_20150318_1630090.jpg P_20150318_1630090.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
夜拍場景(一)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/18f5f/18f5fd186793c61074eb6785e8fcdbce3c4fc60d" alt="20150318_190757.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_190757.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d39f/3d39ffefb0adc82cbad1220c69897cda982b092a" alt="20150318_1907570.jpg 20150318_1907570.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/eb608/eb608ab45a3dbca34d121e52adebc0a6c85becd9" alt="20150318_190803.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_190803.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b4d86/b4d8609391cecbc435be82ba3e2c34bfc02a33c3" alt="20150318_1908030.jpg 20150318_1908030.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 開啟 HDR ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cbd46/cbd46ff740689b8d136ae06af801821d0e225c81" alt="P_20150318_190709.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_190709.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bfbb7/bfbb71c75b4ff5b7dfaab6a5b55ab05b716ec0f8" alt="P_20150318_1907090.jpg P_20150318_1907090.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b98f9/b98f98f7c0a69610a94a49b5af675ca664b3c5bb" alt="P_20150318_190715_NT.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_190715_NT.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c82c7/c82c7b435254062efff941d6adaf965245a852b5" alt="P_20150318_190715_NT0.jpg P_20150318_190715_NT0.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 夜拍模式 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b1f85/b1f8533a9add8fce3593b798d5e7f493b9e42dcf" alt="P_20150318_190720_LL.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_190720_LL.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/60a6e/60a6ed556d864ca9a8392106e56781ce91d7b76a" alt="P_20150318_190720_LL0.jpg P_20150318_190720_LL0.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 低光源模式 (300 萬像素) ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
夜拍場景(二)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/09f83/09f8363f321723eeacb7064dd959bec43a71316e" alt="20150318_190825.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_190825.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/168ce/168ce1a3705523f363c2b503b8c11882203b1652" alt="20150318_1908250.jpg 20150318_1908250.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0f2ab/0f2ab98cf3bd9d5fd0961ede232fba4947be8ca0" alt="20150318_190833.jpg放大鏡圖 20150318_190833.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0f867/0f86746052e83c048dc86f5289f7e42e30cda0c9" alt="20150318_1908330.jpg 20150318_1908330.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 開啟 HDR ▲Galaxy S6 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/08603/086032c6b9632cdae3ec8dcdbd33a40ec1f7a917" alt="P_20150318_190850.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_190850.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6af2e/6af2ec973a44867137d34c22bc47067a19cdc5b3" alt="P_20150318_1908500.jpg P_20150318_1908500.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9533a/9533a81633888488d4e3788f9c5e97142318ade9" alt="P_20150318_190855_NT.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_190855_NT.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4da97/4da970e25391faac9558a45efbfbe05a37ff91bc" alt="P_20150318_190855_NT0.jpg P_20150318_190855_NT0.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 夜拍模式 ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c75a1/c75a13fa000fd08a1baf091e755b78f30773cf3f" alt="P_20150318_190859_LL.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150318_190859_LL.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4a2ac/4a2ac81aa4af107cfac0505573cf96c7de021bcc" alt="P_20150318_190859_LL0.jpg P_20150318_190859_LL0.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 低光源模式 (300 萬像素) ▲ZenFone 2 對焦點原圖裁切
新增 HDR 模式比較:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/59aff/59aff7aa06c70ae30d45b19bc1af48a6a113c97c" alt="20150320_185532.jpg放大鏡圖 20150320_185532.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/63182/63182996eadae058d3fad3c8134326f92c6a1d5c" alt="20150320_1855320.jpg 20150320_1855320.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 自動模式 ▲Galaxy S6 自動模式對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aa71f/aa71f68e38186352071dee5f751cee356dd5075a" alt="20150320_185537.jpg放大鏡圖 20150320_185537.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b797a/b797af6d29c66dcee22a1b0aa4a66eeedd463d34" alt="20150320_1855370.jpg 20150320_1855370.jpg"
▲Galaxy S6 開啟 HDR ▲Galaxy S6 開啟 HDR 對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e0593/e05938a147b10adf2df43c150cad3d91ac5181ca" alt="P_20150320_185450.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150320_185450.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0771c/0771cd8b5c47013ae66cc7a6e1296bb196a29c97" alt="P_20150320_1854500.jpg P_20150320_1854500.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 自動模式 ▲ZenFone 2 自動模式對焦點原圖裁切
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0ff5d/0ff5d78ec03af2e75ce6df40949c873ea2e07fb4" alt="P_20150320_185459_HDR.jpg放大鏡圖 P_20150320_185459_HDR.jpg放大鏡圖"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8b384/8b3845612221767e953e38464451790a9d009ff0" alt="P_20150320_185459_HDR0.jpg P_20150320_185459_HDR0.jpg"
▲ZenFone 2 HDR 模式 ▲ZenFone 2 HDR 模式對焦點原圖裁切
小結:一山還有一山高,ZenFone 2 很不錯,但莫忘一分錢一分貨的道理!
看完以上的成像比較,我們發現定價不過兩千二的 ZenFone 2 表現確實很不錯,對於預算有限的人來說,無疑有非常大的吸引力。但畢竟比的是畫質,因此比較的時候我們還是得先把價格因素給拋開。日拍的當下是下午 4 點多的黃昏時段,其實肉眼看起來東西都稍微偏暖了,但就實拍成像來說,ZenFone 2 有好幾張的白平衡、亮度、色彩表現都很出色,相對於 S6 的表現, S6 在 HDR 效果更顯自然,且比較忠實呈現出現眼睛實際看到的顏色。而這部份的差異屬於各廠調色和發色的風格所導致,比較無法評斷出絕對的優劣,大家可以針對喜好還做選擇。
不過當我們看放大看原圖畫質之後,就可以發現表現 ZenFone 2 的表現並不如原廠所註明的「世界第一」這般強大,雖然兩者銳利度都很不錯,但在清晰度和雜訊抑制表現,ZenFone 2 都遠不如 Galaxy S6。特別是在夜拍的時候,ZenFone 2 不論哪個模式,清晰度都無法跟 S6 的自動模式抗衡,我們也發現當開啟 HDR 功能的時候,Galaxy S6 的夜拍的畫質會更好,且也會更真實呈現出實際的顏色(可以從 Starbucks 的招牌燈發現)。
特別值得注意的是,我們也發現在日拍最後一組蒲公英種子的近拍場景中,Galaxy S6 一次就對焦完成,但 ZenFone 2 對焦 4 次卻都對到地板,只好焦點稍微往指甲的地方移動,才順利完成拍攝。此外,兩款手機在實際拍攝的操作手感也是有差異的,例如拍攝 HDR 的時候,ZenFone 2 拍攝後需要稍作等待,而 S6 則可即時預覽且立刻取得成像,這部份的差異我們則用影片的方式讓大家感受。不知大家又覺得 Galaxy S6 及 Zenfone 2 的表現如何呢?不妨留言分享看法呀。
▲ Asus ZenFone 2 HDR 功能拍照示範。
▲ Samsung Galaxy S6 HDR 功能拍照示範。